Pages

Sunday, 13 June 2021

Ghashiram Kotwal Vijay Tendulkar Book Review

Hello welcome to Powervati Tales. Hope you are doing well.

Today we are talking about this play written in 1972 by Vijay Tendulkar. It was performed and appreciated world over, and of course in India, before it was banned in the state of Maharashtra. The play was written in criticism of the erstwhile ruling party of the state. What is the play about? What was the reason for its ban? Let's look at the reasons what these political plays are trying to achieve and why they offend people. Let us first look at the facts and then at the fiction. 

Facts:

Ghashiram Kotwal is based on a novel written by social activist Moroba Kanhoba Vijaykar in 1863. Ghashiram Kotwal was a real person who was appointed as the police prefect in 1777 by Nana Phadnavis. The Peshwas ruled the Maratha empire under the titular leadership of Chatrapati Shahu Maharaj. This was the most powerful empire of the Deccan and Nana Phadnavis was one of the eight ministers of the court. His brand of politics was a  strange mix of threat and diplomacy which earned him the moniker "Maratha Machiavelli" from the British, since the British had gained a foothold in the politics of North India but found the Peshwas still largely inaccessible. Based on this fact one might assume that the Peshwas had their stuff sorted. But it was only superficially so because the entire clan was ridden with a lot of internal politics. These were the circumstances in which Ghashiram Kotwal was appointed as the police prefect. Ghashiram seemed to enjoy boundless power until his death when Nana Phadnavis ordered for him to be stoned to death. His crime was locking up about forty brahmins in a room where 21 of them suffocated and died. Given that Ghashiram had committed many such crimes (may be not to this degree,) it raises suspicion what might have transpired between the two that put Ghashiram out of Nana's favour.

This is what the play implores. Moroba Kanhoba on whose novel this play is based obviously mixes facts with fiction because that is what fiction does. Vijay Tendulkar does the same because that is how creative liberty works. Other such works of historical fiction are Girish Karnad's Tughlaq, which is sort of a criticism of the Nehruvian era. A more recent example of such work is Hilary Mantel's Wolf Hall, a novel about the rise of Thomas Cromwell.

The entire exercise of literature is to look at our past and examine it without prejudice. The same is the purpose of this play, to study the dynamics between powerful people. And isn't that right? Look at Maharashtra's politics right now. Look at the weird dynamics between the ministers and the police.

Fiction

So that being the intent, this is how Tendulkar uses the facts unknown to people to build his plot. Such as the fact that Nana Phadnavis was a much married man. The time he died, his last marriage was to a nine year old girl called Jiubai. Tendulkar uses these facts to etch out a character of the man that is not much known to the society. It would have been easier for a man like Ghashiram, an outsider to the Peshwa court, to offer his daughter to a man with such weakness, in exchange for a powerful position. 

The purpose of the play is not to defame a man or a community but to look at how powerful people in our society might be making their moves to achieve their own selfish motives instead of the larger good of the society. 

For instance, Ghashiram Kotwal issues a diktat that people cannot leave their homes after sunset. Given our society, we might deduce that this was to keep people safe and away from illegal activities. But instead we see that the Kotwal allows a lot of illegal activities to be carried out freely without any interference of the general society who might object to such activities if they ever saw it.

And Phadnavis who for his own selfish motives allows condones all of this while he remains blameless and orders for Ghashiram to be stoned. He says he does this to bring down a man drunk on power.

These are all universal machination of how the powerfully corrupt people run their show. Be it Saddam Hussein or Trump, when they are done with their power play, they first bring down those people who hoisted them. It is true that Tendulkar may have been commenting on the brahmin society that was assigned the social obligation of enlightening the society but instead they end up exploiting them. Bit overall, it intends to question the system that hands over power to a handful of men while the multitude has to move to their whims.

These are a few things that Tendulkar wants us to dwell on. This play had many other interesting factors. It revives older forms of play based mainly on music. Representing a society that was becoming culturally diverse, abhangas break into laavanis or qawwalis. The sutradhar narrates the happenings in the rhythm of the temple preacher.  

Our society is going through a change. At present it is not apparent but we will have to examine at the actions of the people whom we choose to be our leaders. Certainly then, plays like Ghashiram Kotwal are a good manual of how to look at these circumstances. 

 


Wednesday, 19 May 2021

Alice Hoffman Museum of Extraordinary Things Review

 Reading Pace: Superfast

Genre: Magic Realism, Historical Fiction.

I had watched the movie, Practical Magic, some time in the 90s. I had forgotten its name but I remembered bits of its scenes sometimes, and wondered what the movie was. Recently, when I rediscovered this movie, I wanted to know more about the author. I randomly picked this book, The Museum of Extraordinary Things, based on just the interesting title. As a rule I do not research much about any book before reading it for the fear of spoilers. So I won't tell you what the story is either, but just tell you what to look forward to in this novel.

Alice Hoffman's genre is mainly a blend of historical fiction with fantasy. Many of her books explore the history of America through the lens of Magic. Of course, there is the Native American culture which could be considered a part of the magical tradition. But what Hoffman writes about is a history of modern America.
 

 
 
In this novel, The Museum of Extraordinary Things, she explores a part of history that is largely unknown to the rest of the world. This book is about New York at the turn of the 20th century, more specifically the first decade. A city still becoming what it would be and is going through some sort of growing pains before giving in completely to the assault of relentless capitalism. And capturing this city during this transition is one of the protagonists, Eddie Cohen. Eddie is a young Jewish man, son of a Ukrainian immigrant, who has escaped from the country and from the Russian persecution. He is one of the pair of eyes that captures the changing landscape of New York, growing wistful for a city that is changing too rapidly in front of his eyes. His camera captures all of this. His story gets entangled in the discovery of a possible murder. This is what is magical about Eddie. He is a detective at heart. He just has an instinct for finding people. Through Eddie, Hoffman tells us the story of an accident that revolutionised labour laws in America.
 

The main, protagonist, if we may say so, is Coralie Sardie, daughter of a French immigrant. She is the mermaid but that is not her magic. She is one of the weird creatures at her father's museum. Although the rest of the world had the concept of the circus, America took this thing to a whole new level in what were called the "freak shows". It is exactly what it sounds like, they used to showcase different looking people. It is through her eyes that we see other side of the city. Most importantly, we see a crazy early version of Disneyland called the Dreamland. With no concept of human rights and labour laws in place, we can see the extent to which people could take the concept of entertainment.

 

 
Talking about Hoffman's love for Magick, she is all about realising the feminine power. As Coralie goes through her ordeal, the magic is thrust upon her. She goes from being a literal showpiece to being a woman.

As both the protagonists discover their potential, and each other, they have to fight monsters within them and outside them. Eddie has to fight with his indifference to his own past, he has to fight the emerging face of capitalism. Coralie has to fight her imagined shackles, she has to fight the identity that has been bestowed on her. Both Coralie and Eddie are more attached to their foster parents rather than their biological parents. Hmm is there a metaphor for America somewhere there? 
 
In a way, all the characters of the novel have been rid of their humanness, either willingly or by force and they have to find them, even if it comes at the cost of destroying the material things around them. Eddie's imploration starts with the investigation of the fire at Triangle Shirtwaist Factory and Coralie's imploration ends with the fire at the Dreamland amusement park. These two fires that changed America. But even as the characters find their humanity, we can feel the writer's yearning in whether it was worth it, considering what it was replaced with. 

In conclusion, it is an interesting journey that Hoffman takes us on, a black and white America, so different. This book is a pageturner, and yet it effortlessly informs without breaking the pace when telling the personal stories.

Thursday, 30 May 2019

Writer Daisy Johnson Reader's Book Recommendation

Since I am technologically deficient I know I wouldn't know how to search for this on Twitter later and so here are the highlights of a book recommendation thread started by writer Daisy Johnson...






 







Tuesday, 16 October 2018

Eleanor Catton's Luminaries Review




So what book are we talking about today? The book is called Luminaries. It was Man Booker winner for the year 2013, the second novel written by Eleanor Catton. And in our home, this book is referred to as the Mount Everest,  because these days I look at the page-count before reading a book and by that logic this 800 page mound of a book becomes an unscale-able endeavour. But Powervati 1 and family 0, this book is a real undownputtable.




So what's this book about? The year is 1866 and the setting is New Zealand. The book opens with Walter Moody, a Scotsman raised in England, landing in Hokitikaand finding himself at the parlour of Crown Hotel.  He meets a party of 12 men and a Canterbury Tales style exchange of personal stories begins and eventually a name is mentioned more times than others, Anna Wetherell. Anna and her orange dress. That explains my dress today.

But the real genius of the book lies in bringing under one roof so many people with their own outlook to life and their attitudes, and how they interact and influence the people around them. And what is the motivation for these people to come together? It is circumstances of course, but also a large amount of gold that is lost. Some people have also gone missing, but those are only peripheral problems, a hindrance in finding the gold. 

It is about the dynamics between people, their selfishness, kindness, deep-rooted issues that come to surface as their livelihood or egos or loves have been threatened. So in Luminaries, guiding and motivating its many many characters are the skies above. That's right, the zodiac. So if you are interested in astrology you have a special advantage in reading the characters.

The Booker winning  novels all seem to have this quality. They are not only set in a politically detailed landscape but they are also brilliant in terms of writing as a craft. I will quote some beautiful and insightful lines from the novel later. But as of now let's talk about the structure, because it is the structure that holds the narrative in place.

So what is the structure in Luminaries? The book begins with the part called Sphere within a Sphere. What does that mean? It represents the physical plane, the geological sphere that is our world embedded in the metaphysical sphere that is the skies, where stars move and foretell our luck, or so they say.



There are of course, the 12 characters in the novel that are 12 different zodiac signs. Now you might either think that it is very restrictive because the characters will be bound by the attributes of the zodiac sign or you might think it is an easy way out. But there are many other characters without any zodiac sign mentioned that push their own agendas and keep things interesting. So if you know astrology you will be like, "Oh Pritchard, the misunderstood Scorpion!" or "Oh Ah Sook, this stupid, naive Aquarian." 

It doesn't mean that if you don't know astrology you won't enjoy the book, there are many plot elements with enough twists and turns to keep things interesting.  But if you do understand it, you will know that if a chapter is titled "Mercury in Saggitarius" like the 1st chapter of the book is, you will know that Mercury, the planet of communications is in Sagittarius, the constellation of spiritual awakenings and revelations. So it just means that you have a kind of hint in a book that is a page-turner anyway. 



The strength of the book, amongst many other positives, is that this novel about the 19th century is written in the 19th century English classic novel style. The description of the world, the mannerism of the characters and the language is perfect for this old world thriller. The portrayal takes you back in time, when people wore suits and hats and travelled by ship. And when Moody reaches New Zealand, you will feel the cold, foggy air, and when the incessant rains start, you feel the chill in those wet clothes. And you are there with Walter Moody, feeling the awkwardness of having disturbed a private meeting at the Crown Hotel parlour where the drama unfolds. 

I want to conclude that if you have complained that literary fiction is boring or otherwise that thrillers have no literary merit, this book is a happy confluence of that. The only negative thing you might say about this book is the weight lifting you have to do holding this Hulk of book. Go ahead and read it! :)

Saturday, 10 February 2018

Make A Career in Writing in UAE





Most governments in UAE do not encourage independent businesses that are not channeled
through the government. While helps keep transparency in other professions, other professionals such as writers & artists will notice that there is a blurry line where there work might become an illegal source of income.

While artists continue to live and work here without any governmental opposition, it is better to make sure you work without going cross with the government. And here are the few ways you can earn a livelihood writing in UAE.

Upwork


Upwork is a USA based company that allows anyone to hire freelance writers from around the world. You can create your account, fill the profile with your credentials and accept work from those who offer you projects. Other such sites include fiverr.com

Dubizzle



If you want to work money in UAE itself, there are freezone companies that can hire you as freelancers. Of course you cannot go searching for them but you can ensure they find you. Posting your profile on Dubizzle as an classified ad will help you find work & make contacts.

Blogging


Don't reject this as a waste of time.I know many people who start blogs but many of
us give up because forget making any money we have a tough time finding an engaging audience.
But if you create a niche blog, write regularly & promote it well you can get both money &
audience. My food blog took five years to find money.

Connect With Publishing Houses

If you have already created a portfolio writing for a long time, you can contact
local publishing houses & pitch in your idea for a book. You will need to research well &
be very professional so remember to do your homework well before you take the step.

Find Full Time Writing Job


If you can commit, you can just as easily find job as a content writer. Dubai has constant needs for
technical writers. The pay is decent & you can learn skills that you might miss out if you write
for leisure. I learnt many non-writing related skills such as using Content Management softwares or
using Social Media when it was new & mainstream. Whether you are amateur or if you are already a full time professional, you can find work on jobsites such as naukrigulf, bayt or indeed.ae.

Thursday, 7 December 2017

Kalidas' Abhigyan Shakuntalam Play Review





When I had finished reading Mrichchkatika I had decided I would be reading Kalidasa’s Abhignana Shakuntalam. The first play impressed me much, how did this one fare? So let’s get to it! Kalidasa  was a Sanskrit playwright from 4th-5th AD and was a court poet at Ujjain.

Based on this play, Kalidasa can be called a romantic poet. I am saying this in comparison with two of his contemporaries (more or less,) Shudraka & Bhasa. Kalidasa in this play chooses a story from Mahabharata’s Adi Parva. Mahabharata was the most political literature available to Kalidasa and he chose to explore it as a love story. This story of Shakuntala and Dushyant has immense potential as a socio-political story.
Consider this, Consider this Shakuntala is the daughter of a rishi, a sage, and an apsara, a nymph. Vishwamitra, Shakuntala’s father was the son born through a boon to be a Brahmin to Kshatriya parents. Vishwamitra had to struggle to be called a brahmin because of the complexity of his birth. And Menaka was a celestial nymph. Although it seems mythological in concept but the story is rife with suggestions about casteism. Add to this King Dushyant forgets having been married to Shakuntala, and gets married to another woman. When Shakuntala visits Dushyant he refuses to recognise her, of course there is the plot factor that it was a curse, though it is very telling of a society that takes a man’s word as final. Kalidasa during this time, would have referred to India as Bharata, Dushyant Shakuntala’s son. However, Kalidasa chooses to ignore all these aspects in favour of romance.
It is possible that I may have expected a lot more from poet so celebrated by Eastern scholars as well as Western. Even Arthur William Ryder the author who translated both Shakuntala and Mrichchkatika talks about the rage of Kalidasa in England among the Indophiles. It is also possible that Mrichchkatika may have raised the bar for a good Sanskrit play for me but this is the impression that has on me… This play lacks humour, action and social observation, all of which is exchanged in favour of romance. Although it would be unfair to conclude anything about Kalidasa from one play so I will read more and then let’s see!

Ghashiram Kotwal Vijay Tendulkar Book Review

Hello welcome to Powervati Tales. Hope you are doing well. Today we are talking about this play written in 1972 by Vijay Tendulkar. It was p...